If the treatment target is not achieved in thermal soil treatment, the affected material must be retreated or directed to an alternative disposal route. The exact procedure depends on the nature of the deviation, the contractual agreements, and the applicable waste management regulations. The following sections answer the most important questions on this topic.
What measures follow when a treatment target is not achieved?
If the treatment target is not achieved, the material is generally subjected to post-treatment. In practice, this means the material undergoes the treatment process again, often under adjusted parameters such as higher temperatures or extended residence time in the rotary kiln. Alternatively, it is assessed whether a different disposal route is legally and technically permissible.
In practice, this process follows a structured approach. As soon as analytical results indicate that target values have been exceeded, the affected batch of material is first separated and placed in interim storage. A technical root cause analysis is then carried out. Only after this is a decision made as to whether repeating the thermal desorption is appropriate or whether the material must be directed to a secured landfill. Premature release of improperly treated soils is not permitted under waste law and can trigger significant liability risks.
How is it determined whether the treatment target has been achieved?
The verification of treatment success is carried out through analytical sampling of the treated material. After thermal soil treatment, samples are taken and analyzed in the laboratory for the relevant contaminants. The results are compared with the target values defined contractually or by the authorities.
Sampling follows established procedures based on relevant standards and the requirements of the competent authorities. Typically, eluate analyses and solid-matter analyses are carried out to ensure that both the contaminant levels in the material and the leaching behavior comply with the limit values. For complex contaminations such as PAHs, PCBs, or PFAS, extended analytical packages are required. The sampling itself must be representative, as inhomogeneous batches can lead to distorted results. A well-conceived quality management system is therefore crucial for the validity of the analytical results.
What are the typical causes of a missed treatment target?
The most common causes of an unachieved treatment target in contaminated site remediation are inadequate characterization of the input material, fluctuating material properties, and suboptimal process parameters. Unexpected combinations of contaminants can also impair treatment success.
In detail, the following factors play a role:
- Mischaracterization: If the preliminary investigation of the contaminated soil was incomplete, contaminants may be present that were not accounted for in the treatment concept.
- Material inhomogeneity: Soils from contaminated sites are often highly heterogeneous. Heavily contaminated zones within a batch can negatively affect the overall analytical results.
- Process parameters: Residence times that are too short in the rotary kiln or temperatures that are too low result in semi-volatile contaminants not being fully driven off.
- Contaminant complexity: Certain compounds such as highly chlorinated PCBs or specific PFAS compounds require higher temperatures or a specific process management approach.
- Material moisture: An excessively high water content in the feed material can significantly reduce thermal efficiency.
Understanding these causes is a prerequisite for initiating targeted countermeasures and adapting the treatment concept accordingly.
Can treated material still be landfilled or reused?
Whether material that has not been fully treated can be landfilled or reused depends on the actually measured contaminant levels and the applicable limit values. Reuse is only possible if the limit values of the relevant regulations are met. Otherwise, disposal at a suitable, approved facility is the only legally compliant option.
Different landfill classes apply depending on the level of contamination. Material that does not meet the assignment values for a Class DK I landfill must be deposited at a Class DK II or DK III landfill. Utilization in earthworks or as a construction material is not an option if the requirements of the Federal Soil Protection and Contaminated Sites Ordinance (BBodSchV) or the Substitute Building Materials Ordinance are not met. Material flow management plays an important role here in identifying the legally permissible and economically viable disposal route for each batch of material.
What contractual and legal consequences arise?
If the treatment target is not achieved, this can give rise to warranty claims, obligations to remedy defects, and in the worst case, claims for damages. The specific consequences depend on the contractual structure of the treatment agreement and the regulatory requirements.
From a legal perspective, a distinction must be made between whether a works contract or a service contract is in place. Under a works contract, the contractor owes a defined outcome, namely compliance with the agreed target values. If this is not achieved, the client is generally entitled to remediation. In addition, regulatory requirements arising from the approval notice for the remediation project may be relevant. Anyone acting as a waste generator or waste holder remains legally responsible under waste law until proper disposal has been demonstrated. Comprehensive documentation of the treatment process and analytical results is therefore not only professionally essential but also legally indispensable.
How can the risk of a missed treatment target be minimized?
The risk of an unachieved treatment target can be significantly reduced through careful preliminary investigation of the material, a realistic definition of targets, and experience-based process management. It is crucial that the treatment target and material characteristics are aligned from the outset.
The following measures are specifically recommended:
- Comprehensive incoming analysis: Before acceptance, the material should be analyzed for all relevant contaminants, including rare compounds such as nitroaromatics or PCDD/PCDF.
- Realistic target value definition: Treatment targets must be technically achievable. Target values below the process detection limit will inevitably lead to problems.
- Process control: Continuous monitoring of kiln temperature, residence time, and material moisture during thermal treatment enables early intervention.
- Experience-based process management: Many years of operational experience with a wide variety of contamination types is a decisive factor in correctly setting process parameters.
- Accompanying quality assurance: Intermediate sampling during treatment provides early indications of possible deviations before an entire batch is released.
Close coordination between the client, expert assessor, and treatment facility is essential throughout. The better the initial situation is documented, the more precisely the treatment concept can be designed.
How ARE Deutzen GmbH provides support when a treatment target is not achieved
ARE Deutzen GmbH has more than 30 years of experience in thermal soil treatment and is well acquainted with the challenges surrounding treatment targets from daily practice. With a high-performance facility at the Deutzen site and an experienced team, ARE Deutzen offers concrete solutions when a treatment target has been missed or when the risk of failure needs to be minimized:
- Technical root cause analysis in the event of deviations from the treatment target
- Post-treatment of material batches with adjusted process parameters in the rotary kiln (up to approximately 600 °C, depending on material composition and contaminant load)
- Identification of alternative disposal routes within the framework of material flow management
- Comprehensive documentation and analysis for legally compliant verification
- Advice on realistic target definition already during the project planning phase
- Interim storage of materials until the appropriate disposal route has been determined
If you have questions about an ongoing project or would like to proactively assess the risk of an unachieved treatment target, contact ARE Deutzen directly. Get in touch now and receive expert assessment of your specific situation.