The following core information is typically required for a technical feasibility assessment: waste type and contaminant spectrum, origin and quantity of the material, current analytical data, and relevant regulatory documents. The more complete and precise this information is, the faster and more reliably the assessment can be carried out. The sections below explain each of these points in detail.
What waste properties must be known before the feasibility assessment?
Before the technical feasibility assessment, the essential properties of the material to be treated must be known: waste type (e.g., soil, construction rubble, slag), physical characteristics (grain size, moisture content, consistency), and the contaminant spectrum. Without this basic information, it is not possible to determine whether and under what conditions thermal treatment is technically feasible.
The type of contamination is particularly relevant. Different contaminants require different treatment temperatures and process engineering settings. Volatile hydrocarbons such as BTEX or TPH behave differently in a rotary kiln than semi-volatile compounds such as PAHs, PCBs, or PCDD/PCDF. Mercury (Hg) also occupies a special position, as it transitions to a gaseous state at low temperatures and places particular demands on flue gas treatment.
In addition, physical properties play a decisive role. A high moisture content increases energy requirements and affects throughput. Coarse, stony material must be mechanically processed before thermal treatment. The loss on ignition — that is, the organic fraction in the material — is also an important parameter for process design.
What quantity and origin information is needed for the assessment?
The feasibility assessment requires information on the total quantity of material to be treated, the planned delivery period, and the origin of the waste. This information is necessary to plan capacities, evaluate logistical requirements, and assess the permitting situation.
The origin of the material is not only logistically relevant. It provides clues about possible contamination sources and helps to classify the contaminant profile. Soil from a former gasworks site typically contains PAHs and cyanides, while material from military sites is frequently contaminated with nitroaromatics or chlorinated solvents. This contextual knowledge greatly facilitates the evaluation of existing analytical data.
The planned delivery quantity also influences whether interim storage at the treatment site is required and at what frequency transports need to be coordinated. Projects involving large quantities over a long period require different planning than one-off, compact remediation measures.
Why are analytical data and sampling reports so critical?
Analytical data and sampling reports are the most important basis for any technical feasibility assessment in soil treatment. They document the type and concentration of contaminants, record sampling carried out in accordance with recognized standards, and enable a well-founded assessment of whether the material can be treated in the existing facility and what process parameters should be applied.
What is decisive is not only the existence of analytical data, but their quality and currency. Sampling should have been carried out in accordance with recognized standards (e.g., DIN EN ISO 10381), and the results should provide a representative picture of the entire material stream. Individual spot measurements are often insufficient to capture the variability of contamination across the entire excavation.
Sampling reports provide additional information on sampling depth, the location of sampling points, and possible inhomogeneities in the subsurface. This information is valuable when it comes to estimating worst-case scenarios for treatment and incorporating safety margins into the process design. Incomplete or methodologically questionable analyses can lead to delays or additional requirements at a later stage.
What regulatory documents and permits must be available?
For the feasibility assessment, all regulatory documents relating to the waste and the remediation project should be available: in particular classification notices, disposal certificates, remediation orders, or official statements on the planned measure. These documents clarify the legal framework and are a prerequisite for proper disposal.
Particularly relevant is the waste law classification of the material. Depending on the contaminant concentration and waste code, different requirements apply to transport, documentation, and the disposal route. Hazardous waste is subject to the documentation obligation under the Waste Verification Ordinance (NachwV) and requires an electronic disposal certificate (eEN).
If an official remediation order is in place, it frequently already contains specifications regarding the disposal route or quality assurance measures. Such specifications must be taken into account during the technical assessment. Information on ongoing or completed contaminated site investigations at the site of origin can also considerably facilitate the evaluation.
How does the technical feasibility assessment proceed after the documents are received?
After all relevant documents have been received, the specialist team first assesses whether the material is fundamentally suitable for thermal desorption. Process parameters, capacities, and any required pre-treatment steps are then evaluated. The result is a technical assessment of whether and under what conditions treatment is possible.
In detail, the assessment comprises the following steps:
- Review of analytical data: Comparison of the measured contaminant concentrations with the approved input parameters of the facility.
- Evaluation of physical properties: Assessment of whether grain size, moisture, and consistency permit direct thermal treatment or whether mechanical pre-treatment is necessary.
- Capacity and scheduling: Assessment of whether the desired quantities can be processed within the planned timeframe.
- Regulatory review: Comparison of waste codes and contaminant parameters with the existing facility permits under the Federal Immission Control Act.
- Feedback and follow-up queries if necessary: In the event of ambiguities or missing data, a targeted follow-up query is made before a final result is communicated.
The result of the feasibility assessment forms the basis for a concrete offer and further project planning. Depending on the complexity of the material, the assessment can take anywhere from a few days to several weeks.
What happens if project data are incomplete or contradictory?
If project data are incomplete or contradictory, no conclusive technical feasibility assessment can be carried out. In such cases, missing information is specifically requested or additional sampling is recommended. A preliminary assessment is sometimes possible, but does not replace a complete review.
Contradictory analytical data — for example, strongly diverging measured values from different sampling rounds — are a common problem in contaminated site remediation. They may indicate an inhomogeneous distribution of contaminants in the subsurface, but may also point to methodological errors in sampling or analysis. In any case, such discrepancies must be clarified before treatment in order to rule out risks to the facility, operations, and the environment.
Missing regulatory documents can also delay the process. Without a legally valid disposal certificate, hazardous waste may not be accepted. It is therefore advisable to compile all relevant documents at an early stage of the project and to make contact with the treatment facility at an early stage. Open communication about the actual state of the data saves time and avoids misunderstandings in the further course of the project. Information on material flow management helps to maintain an overview of all relevant material streams.
How ARE Deutzen GmbH supports the technical feasibility assessment
ARE Deutzen GmbH has specialized in the treatment of contaminated mineral waste for over 30 years and supports clients from the initial project inquiry through to completed disposal. The technical feasibility assessment is a central first step that the specialist team carries out in a structured and reliable manner.
As part of the assessment, ARE Deutzen specifically offers:
- Evaluation of analytical data and sampling reports by experienced specialists
- Comparison of contaminant parameters with the permits of the thermal soil treatment facility
- Assessment of necessary pre-treatment steps through mechanical-physical treatment
- Clarification of regulatory requirements and waste law classifications
- Transparent feedback even in the case of incomplete data, with concrete recommendations for completion
If you are planning a remediation project and would like to know whether your material is suitable for thermal desorption, please contact us directly. The ARE Deutzen team will review your documents and provide you with a well-founded, practical assessment.